1. The three ways that newcomers try to belong in a new
community are engagement, imagination and alignment. Engagement is finding a
common ground between yourself and old-timers as Wenger says. It is creating
relationships and finding common things between the two groups. Imagination is
trying to extend your knowledge and broaden your thinking. It is trying to
picture a new world and trying to find your place inside of it. Trying to
connect what you are doing with a broader and bigger picture. Alignment is also
finding common ground but in a different way, it is using artifacts and objects
to look at commonalities. It causes you to broaden your discourse and viewing
other people’s goals and ambitions and aliening them with yours. These all can
come with negatives though. Engagement can cause hard feelings if there is a
lack of mutuality. Imagination can be disconnected and ineffective. Alignment can
be a crushing blow on your personal identity.
3. The conflicts between Alan and his work community did not
have positive results because Alan refused to put the correct amount of work
and effort in it that he should have been putting into it. Like Wardle says he
clung to his own ways of writing and communicating. He stayed stubborn and
refused to open up or even perceive new ways. Like the above question, it
showed the people around him that he refused to show engagement, imagination
and alignment. He couldn’t imagine himself as a worker in that workplace. Therefore
the people around him decided to put just as much effort into Alan as Alan was
putting into them. Alan no longer felt he fit in. This all could have been very
different if Alan would have showed he had engagement, imagination and
alignment. He could have showed involvement and willing to change and his
workplace would have accepted him more.
5. I think I agree with both of them. Although what Gee says
that you will always carry with you your dominant Discourse, it is able to be
manipulated and changed. I believe it can actually be completely gone away with
all together. If you really want to completely change the person you are than
you can. So although Alan’s dominant Discourse had a lot of affect and control
on what he believed in and how he acted towards his new work place, if he would
have given it his all and actually wanted to adapt he probably could have done
it. People change all the time and if you really want it then it is easy. This is
where I disagree with Gee because I believe he really could have worked to fit
in in that workplace.
7. My teachers are an example of an institutionally ascribed
authority. I think every teacher is definitely not perfect and when they
disagree with something you have to say then they do seem to sort of loose
their authority. If someone who is supposed to be ahead of you, you are
automatically supposed to respect them but if they don’t respect you then you
lose respect for them. Or maybe that’s just how I think. When they degrade you or do something that you
do not believe is right, it is hard to maintain that respect for them that you
have and to see them as your authority when you believe they are completely
wrong.
No comments:
Post a Comment